Office of Steam Forum for Model & Toy Steam Gas & Hot Air Engines
Builds, Repairs, Show Your Machines! => Technical Tips, Builds, and Help => Topic started by: RON on March 23, 2019, 06:09:04 am
-
@RON any updates?
-
Daniel i think you have hit the nail on the head a flywheel with pins seems to ring a bell at that time there was no photo of the set up and maybe i was the only one that thought the piston stopped at the same place every time but your explaination using servos makes sense would like to see a photo from anyone if possible i think it would make a good winter project maybe flywheels with different weights would stop the piston at a different place. Many thanks for that input.
CBWho i`m afraid your knowledge of steam far outstrips mine and i don`t know how i could reply again many thanks for your input
-
If my memory serves, the method I'm thinking of to make a single cylinder engine self starting has something to do with putting pins in the flywheel with a set orientation to TDC & BDC and then having a linkage connected with the throttle / reverser valve such that when the valve is opened the linkage pushes on the flywheel pin enough to ensure that the engine is moved off TDC / BDC in such a way that it can have a chance at self-starting. I believe the set-up that I recall was servo actuated, so the linkage was perhaps a bit easier to hook-up.
I haven't found the actual bookmark to this yet, but given the number of steam related bookmarks that infest my computer, that is not at all surprising. ;c)
-
A steam choke instead of inlet valve might do that. That's because there will be a buffer of steam that the piston stops against. At least I suspect so...
On a full size, if you move the wolf gear to the center and then shut off the steam it will be generally restartable.
-
Daniel i`m not a 100% sure but i think it was a Wilesco don`t remember the name or the number for the sake of argument let`s call it model x but it was an early version of model x the later version of model x did not have the same functions which i think made the early version rarer that`s how
i understood it the early version of model x was made so that the piston always stopped in the same position and i assume that would be just after TDC. when the press was on making it a self starter. Jan must have described it because at the back of my mind it had something to do with the flywheel what that exactly was i also don`t remember but at the time i thought it was clever. When i try to do a search there has been so many post`s its now a hundred miles down the road. So i think the question should be reversed i.e.who made a stationary engine that the piston always stopped in the same position and how did that work.
-
Not entirely sure what Jan (classix) may have been referencing, but I do recall that there was a method to prevent a single cylinder engine from coming to a stop at top or bottom dead center, thus giving it a chance, but only a chance, of being able to self-start, if not acting against too much resistance. I'll look through my old references and see if I can find anything on it.
Just thinking about it now however, it seems that it would need to be a double acting single cylinder engine to have much chance of actually working in practice.
-
Really not much room except externally look at #53. Forgot Mamod made trains but the thought of a handbrake type appeals. Memory not that great may have been the other forum but i did ask the question of engine self starting and it was classixs (member of this forum) who came up with the answer from memory it was a single acting cylinder stationary engine make i don`t remember but certainly not British but again i don`t remember if he explained how. So classixs if you remember it would be nice now if you came fwd and gave us the answer. Still cleaning.
-
what room do you have for the for/rev device ??
A simpler one as per the mamod toy trains may be a better job
The engine still wont reliably start and will only need a push when you dont want it
-
Hi Frazer for the moment i have to say i`m beat the reason i bought this valve was because it was microcosm but in reality it`s really too large even if everything worked there is no room to mount it on the platform will just have to go in the spare bin put it down to my lack of knowledge. State of affairs at the moment the platform has been stripped and the servo opening moved back 1/4"now they can be replaced without having to remove the engine just needs a clean up and paint and from now on everything put on the platform will stay on
[attach=1]
The body shell too will need a clean up and paint tailboat fairing came in not too bad tried to copy the 1906 cad. model K not exact so will have to call it semi-scale everything fits except the rev valve
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
So you see still much to be done. Once done it will be time to revisit the burner hoping it will just be the case of distance below the boiler or wick size so will be off air for a little while as they say
Best regards
RON
-
Would it be possible to mount the for/rev under the chassis and make a lever along the lines of an old style hand brake lever
I think Iv recently seen someone on BloOOo forum doing a restart device
It maybe possible to make something like a motorcycle kickstart
Im sure there is another idea knocking about in a model boat the drawings are on the web just cannot remember how they did it or if its of any use
The boats name was LaMoutte 1908
cheers
-
That website is amazing but so is what you are doing.
-
Don`t know where to really start the rev control valve arrived early but only now had time to connect it unfortunately i don`t have the correct size tube so i did my best with pvc.
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
Lo and behold the first time i switched the comp on it self started next time it did not out of about 20 times 6 times it did rev/fwd so on average we have to say failure. If only a way could be found to stop the cylinder at a specific point ( magnet on the flywheel maybe ) then it might work. Still feel there is potential just need someone with a good brain the other point is how is this controller mounted it may just be to big to mount on the platform otherwise i`m only going to have a car that is steerable.
-
My goodness there are a lot of beautiful models on that site really goes to show there are some really talented people about, myself i`m not on the same planet. The problem i faced was cutting through the bend at an angle if you can follow makes it narrower at the rear than the front a real tinsmith would have no problem but for me i did say tricky.
[attach=1]
You can see there is a continuous lug but not much help, going to have to move the servos back 1/4" so i think a bit of a strip is in order if at first---. do have things in mind so all is not lost.
-
A bit of inspiration from the master
http://www.wworkshop.net/Home_Page_/Home_Page.html
When I made my Morgan Beetle back I used copper for the body work as it was for me a little easier to form and I got it for free from an old domestic water tank.Still using bits of it 20 years later
Would it be possible to solder a tongue onto the part so it locates
cheers
-
Hi Frazer sorry for late reply did as you suggested and there was a flicker of the flywheel but because i was just holding the airline it stopped maybe be if it was properly connected it might work if a reversing controller was fitted and to that end there is one on order. Further update on the body shell not going to good
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
Can`t really sort the gap between the top cover and the side as above photo on the real car there seems to be a sort of cover but to replicate on a model to my eyes does not look nice so will have a rethink back to the corn flake packets there is no substitute for making a mock up first this time i won`t say which. Regarding the r c side depending how components are laid will depend the model and as you can see there is tonnes of room
[attach=5]
[attach=6]
-
It is a double acting piston valved engine >The trick is the wee bit on the end of the crank just a disc with two pins and when the fore/reverse goes from one way to tuther the arm pushes the engine over the dead center allowing it to restart. It was an idea I first came across in a Model Engineer mag around the mid 1950s on a single cylinder wobbler
I doubt youre crank shaft ported engine will reverse but you could simply swap inlet over to exhaust to see what happens .Just with an airline would prove it
Keep plodding on
cheers
-
(https://ih1.redbubble.net/image.490263184.2295/ap,550x550,16x12,1,transparent,t.png)
-
Impressive!
-
The rear end can`t make a tailboat fairing this time so will try 1906 Cadillac model k folding tonneau except it will just plug in
[attach=1]
The former
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
[attach=5]
Bit tricky but will see what i can do
-
Frazer a terrific video not quite sure what i`m looking at looks like pistons in what to me looks like part of the cylinder you and i will have much to discuss once i get this shell out of the road if it`s single acting cylinders then the so called experts are wrong will contact you later along with Sandy. Charlie your some man follow your exploits when i find time hope you are well.
This might bore some of you and again maybe not
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
-
A great thread that just keeps getting better Ron.
I have nothing technical to add, but I am a great fan of this build.
Looking forward to the next update! 🤠
-
This may help
https://youtu.be/LG8fiJMXzhg
-
Frazer once again to the rescue not quite sure what is happening looks like two single acting cylinders with a controller on top. I do understand a DOUBLE acting TWIN will self start but that`s about it. This engine i`m using is not an oscillating one i think the porting is in the shaft and i thought something that you are showing ( first time i have seen it )might be the answer. Maybe i`m dreaming but i think i saw somewhere maybe same site someone made a device that flicked the flywheel extra servo ?. Would be nice if someone had the gear and tried it and let us know i don`t have that type of gear yet reason for popping the question is really i`m trying to think ahead still a long way to go.
Once again many thanks
Best regards
-
If its a single acting engine it wont self start without some form of mechanical aid along the lines of the French Typhoon engine
Some drawings on this site in the marine section its just a simple disc type of controller it will give forward/reverse and speed from one servo
http://www.vapeur45.fr/chaloupe-a-vapeur/presentation-moteur
-
Nick you are a hard man the problem with building multiple cars is the wheels i know for some people they find it easy for me i`m not that good. Truthfully what i would like to see is someone else having a go there are people out there who can take this to another level the concept is really simple and i think within most peoples abilities but when it comes to steam i`m really the stage before the novice would be nice for others to have a go if they like model cars and show me how i can make fwd/rev. really such a nice engine you only have to touch the flywheel and away it goes so would be really nice if someone has the same engine and let us know if self start is possible. A lot on this week finding time a bit tricky
Regards
RON
P.S. if anyone needs any sizes just ask
-
Now the hard bit what shell to choose...
I will make it easy for you ;) Build all three! :D :D
-
Keep the photos coming Ron.
-
Looks like you are set to go with R/C gear, but do check with the regs regarding what use each frequency can be used for, and realize that you can be liable for damages should you turn your system on and crash someone else's model as a result.
You are likely fully aware of this, but offered just in case you are not.
-
I know this is a steam forum but just a quickie checked out my radio gear thought it was up in my attic but instead in a drawer at my feet 8 transmitters receivers don`t ask
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
So you can see these will fit but feel ashamed to use 7 channel when i only need two
[attach=3]
3rd photo shows my setup when i did some indoor flying last one shows spare one in a box and there both 2 channel the servos are even smaller than the ones i have fitted on the platform
So i think i`m OK for gear ballsed up the photos
-
Oooooh I do love that Contractor's Van and the great room it would give for accommodating ..... well, most anything really, from boilers to R/C gear. I also like the flywheel peeking out from under the frame between the wheels.
Meanwhile I really love the sedan that you are attempting, and the challenges of not having all that extra space.
-
Bonnet/hood
I thought the first place to start was to make a former
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
Simply bent round the former the only mistake i made i should have softened the brass first it was a bit springy
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
[attach=5]
The front was soldered with lead free solder the side with silver solder was going to try and beat it round a former like boiler end caps but thought this way much neater
[attach=6]
[attach=7]
Now the hard bit what shell to choose the r/x will fit any but i don`t know the battery dimensions
[attach=8]
[attach=9]
[attach=10]
So you see it`s really hard to choose the first t/x i had was valve operated the r/x was reed operated both home made ( forget from which mag it came from ) since moved on but still my radio gear is quite old will need to hunt the net to see if there is any mini stuff so will really need to think hard
-
Sandy once again thanks for your input have sent PM to Scott so let`s hope this works have cooled down a little. Have a look at #33 of this post and you will see the boiler steamed up after 2mins using a different burner now it takes 6mins so i think the problem must lye with the burner i.e. heat output. Think i will put the steam side on hold not the end of the world but certainly a setback really need more trials. Will crack on with the body shell meaning more formers and templates need to be made at least i`m miles ahead of where i was a month ago. Would have liked to introduced fwd/rev but not sure if it can be done with this engine so you see still lots to think about. I`m at the stage when i watch the telly i see moving pictures but my brain is on another planet.
-
Hi RON,
Sent you a PM. I hope we can resolve this issue quickly and to your satisfaction.
Regards,
Scott
The Office of Steam Forum for Model & Toy Steam Gas & Hot Air Engines Team
-
Sent message to moderator will get back to you another day really makes me angry
-
Sandy many thanks for your excellent response twice now i have posted a reply and i get error occurred or no permission and so on maybe i`m taking too long to reply
-
. Can anyone tell me how small can a burner/boiler be that will run for 5mins
Hi Ron,
The size of a boiler required to run for 5 minutes can only be determined of the following are known: -
a/ The total swept volume of the engine being run by the boiler.
b/ The rpm of the engine.
c/ The working pressure of the boiler.
These 3 items will determine the amount of water which needs to be evaporated at the working pressure for a 5 minute run time.**
Once the amount of water required is known then the amount of heat (in Btu's) required to perform the evaporation rate can be determined which, once known, can then be used to calculate the amount of fuel (Meths) that will be needed to run for 5 minutes... which in turn will determine the number and size of flames required.
It's all a matter of balancing the output requirements with the input required to achieve the desired results and also allow for losses, of which there will be a good few.
It is not really possible to just pick a size and expect it all to work unless you are very very lucky.
So, more info will be required in order to work things out properly.
One or two things to note... 1/ **A boiler should never be run completely dry, so it must hold more water than actually required... 2/ The amount of fuel provided should always run out before the boiler water.
I do like the project you are working on and I am sure it can be made to work as desired, but some extra math is going to need to be done I am afraid if you are to get the best results from your efforts.
If I can help with that then don't be afraid to ask.
From your last post I would suggest you only put 1.25- 1.5 mils of meths in the burner and see how long that runs for.
I hope this is of some help.
Best regards.
Sandy.
-
Stoker many thanks for your kind words and to others who contribute did some more trials
[attach=1]
This is what it looks like when first lit
[attach=2]
once it settles
[attach=3]
Wick now raised 2mm now you can just see orange appearing at the tip don`t know if it make any difference to the heat output maybe someone can tell me ( have already written a reply but nothing happened must have pressed the wrong button)so i will be brief . This burner will run for 20mins with 5mls of meths no matter what i do which is really too long for what i want. Can anyone tell me how small can a burner/boiler be that will run for 5mins
-
Fear not Ron, there are others following this thread too .... myself, most definitely among them!
I'm finding your combination of design ahead and design as you go to be a very interesting and seemingly successful approach.
I most certainly like what I'm seeing, and have great hopes for you eventually achieving the vehicle of your original mock-up dreams.
-
Frazer many thanks for both articles the second one is where i got the idea the man in question i don`t know his name but he in turn said that he found it in some Forum which one he does not say so i don`t claim it`s my idea what i`m using is a Bronze mesh wick and i will enjoy adjusting it over the weekend. Getting back to your" wee pie wagon " i think that would be a great challenge don`t know if i have such skills Ford made a "Paddy Wagon" (Police van )and has a very similar body shape but there are so many to choose from. What makes me happy this morning is someone is following the post .
Best regards
RON
-
http://www.roundhouse-eng.com/spirit.htm
http://www.vapeuretmodelesavapeur.com/alcoolabruler/index.html
-
Just before posting THIS thread i thought i would just check it out with air it runs across my desk just like before would have felt stupid if it didn`t but it does and i`m really impressed little bit early to think of the final image but it`s always on my mind. At the moment the burner is still my priority i can now tell different designs have different properties i know there are people out there who know about such things but i don`t please accept this is the first time i have done such a thing and my two priorities are the length of burn and it must be clean the first may be controlled by the amount of fuel i put in the tank or maybe not the dia. of the wick must play its part but you guy`s already know that. Secondly it must be clean by that i mean a nice blue flame i think the "Holy Grail" when it comes to burners a candle flame only puts soot on your boilers. Working with meths during the daytime i find hard to see the flame so need to find a way to darken the daylight maybe an upturned cardboard box which i don`t have but will need to think of something the following pics might interest some of you
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
So you see i have reached the "Holy Grail" if you have not seen a burner of this type with a blue flame you have now
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
I did a little tweak with the height of the wick and i can see a little difference in the flame this was done in the house just to get the pics and i thought maybe enough in case things get out of hand. Today is my Great grand daughters birthday so you know where i`m going tomorrow shopping so it will be the weekend before i can try out further trials. Will report further but i think i`m winning.
-
Nicely done so far, and it's really taking shape with your template 8)
-
Boiler now complete in fact the whole under frame is now complete
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
As you can see the frame is only held on by 6 10ba screws
[attach=5]
[attach=6]
[attach=7]
[attach=8]
Only an idea it is now at the stage i could steam it up and see what happens but the real problem is the burner i cannot understand why it burns so long with only 5mls of meths can`t see a restriction but there is something not correct. Could be the wick holder is too long but truthfully i have no idea so really can`t give any further update until the problem is resolved was going to try some tests today but just to warm in the greenhouse, when i said it burns too long the initial flame is quite high then it peters out with the flame quite small really need to find an answer. Might be a clue in the background.
-
Thanks for the update Ron!
You did a really nice job on the burner.
Great progress.
-
Fitting of the burner, attached to the platform by a threaded ring the two holes in the ring is so i can tighten it with a lens spanner
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
The other thing to watch out for is the spacing of the wick below the boiler dispite my mistake in sizing it looks not too bad the only other thing i have to do is to make an adaptor for the boiler outlet pipe i want it to run down vertical at 90degrees and that should really take care of all things below the waterline.
Bit slow this month due birthdays,family visits, shopping and so on but still progress
-
The burner
[attach=1]
[attach=2
][attach=3]
[attach=4]
More to the burner than meets the eye was going to make one using a copper end cap the ones i have are too small the next size too big so i more or less fabricated one was aiming to make one just holding 7mils as it turned out this one holds about 12mls far too big but i`m stuck with it. The wick holder you can see is longer than the tank i read somewhere that the fuel level in the tank should be below the level of the wick holder now when the tank is filled with 5mls of meths it does not reach half way i could see that when i was checking for leaks you could hardly see anything in the wick holder so i have really made a mistake regarding sizes. Now hears the rub with 5mls of meths it ran for 20mins YES 20mins and would like to hear from anyone who knows about burners why this should have happened the flame at first was large then at the end flame smaller but would still burn your hand
-
Any update Ron?
-
There's a lot of good work in this one. Keep it up.
-
Getting there 8)
-
Thanks for the update Ron.
-
I am really enjoying your build thread Ron.
Thank you for the detailed pictures and narratives.
Regards,
Charlie
-
.
Works mechanically so should be alright when radio gear installed
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
Will make something nicer when radio gear installed have seen other steering examples where 4 or more rods are used maybe it`s something to do with king pins but with this set up only one rod is required. Will need to extract the digit and get on with the burner.
Last pic might interest some of you crocodile hair clips 50 for £1.99 handy for soldering not extra strong but i think handy
-
Steering two strips of brass 2.5 x 7mm soften first
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
formers attached using 5min epoxy then squeezed in a vice
[attach=3]
Principle OK but the bend to tight
[attach=4]
so really was a case of light tin bashing
[attach=5]
[attach=6]
Axle now fitted but forgot to drill holes for linkage will do that next time i strip it
[attach=7]
[attach=8]
[attach=9]
Takes me back to the 40`s where the boys ( lucky ones although i never had one ) used to run about in their go-karts steering principle the same except they used their feet. Now i think it`s time to make cut outs for the servos think i will fit two the only place they can really go is either side of the prop shaft just behind the cylinders the other thing is where to position the burner tank ( still to make ) position of all three is really important that will determine what type of body i can make hoping it can be a roadster of sorts will now have to make patterns to see exactly where thing can go.
-
Thanks to B & Q i.e. 1" ali angle lets me get the back end sorted out
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
Hopefully now you can see where i`m going
[attach=4]
[attach=5]
[attach=6]
[attach=7]
Still unsure what i`m really going to do about the front still want to make it steerable but i don`t want to use king pins. Looking at the 1902 Cadillac i don`t see king pins front axle looks like a girder of sorts and i think a through back to locomobiles certainly by 1903 they did have king pins, i like the front axle arrangement of the Ford model T but make it rotate like the Mamod steam roller something along those lines still thinking.
Saw a video of a 1905 Cadillac start up procedure made my day like some of you i had car with a starting handle and you know it was fitted below the radiator at the front if you see a photo of a 1905 Cadillac chassis right in the middle is a flywheel and the starting handle goes through the left hand side of the chassis to turn the flywheel to start the engine and so on really never knew that
-
Looking good Ron 8)
-
Have now made the final frame would like to call it a chassis but you can see it`s really a frame it took me 3 attempts to get there the first 2 times the frame buckled after silver soldering i`m not sure but it may have been me cooling it with water
[attach=1]
This is my third attempt and this time i didn`t cool it . It was pinned between 2 dural plates i thought the dural would melt while soldering but it never surprised but that`s what happened
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
Now it`s really a case of transferring components
[attach=4]
[attach=5]
Two mods using a nylon worm and the two bolts that keep the shaft inline replaced by a brass angle with a slot cut out same size as the shaft dia.
The body shell will be bolted to the top (when made ) should be simple enough my immediate problem now is how to secure the axles this time i want to make it steerable easier said than done so really have a lot to think about.
-
Ditto !
Well done so far (https://emoji.tapatalk-cdn.com/emoji482.png)
-
very interesting, I'm certainly following along now.
-
Boiler now installed
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
My thoughts now turned towards the burner
[attach=3]
What you see is the burner from my Genny Wren some thing like that only larger or a fuel tank along the back of the seats like the previous pic shown ( yellow one ) not sure but i think it`s an 1906 Ford
[attach=4]
I thought this might interest some people playing with it on my desk using the small compressor i added some weight and what you see amounts to 886 grams i think i could have pushed it to 1kg or more so now i think it`s time to get serious. Anyone interested making a car you are welcome to copy what i have just done and believe me it WORKS apart from the initial cost of the engine the rest so inexpensive and i`m sure your skills are better than mine you will have one up and running in no time. Now i think it`s time i looked at some chassis i might continue to get it running on steam but at the end of the day it will be stripped and the same components used in dare i say a scale model.
Tell me you don`t like this
[attach=5]
-
Great progress report, and I definitely like the new wheels !
I like the new wheels as well
-
A while ago i bought two cars incomplete, parts missing and so on makers name i don`t know but i think an expensive kit in its time the idea was to replicate them in metal then this project came along i.e. mini steam car
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
You can see the boiler would fit the engine would if i widened the chassis a little i like the idea of the fuel tank behind the seats so something like that i will need to think about for the mini.
The next one
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
A little smaller but more complete so i don`t think i will touch it the wheels are more or less the same patern but a little smaller 1 3/4" also the steering works
The wheels, top one i did think of making a mold an casting them in metal but need to finish this one first hopefully job for the summer so you see i`m still a long way off and many things to think about but i`m enjoining it.
Wheels makes a change from seeing Mamod ones all the time
-
Great progress report, and I definitely like the new wheels !
-
Well i hope you can hear the word "eureka" now i am really winning what you are looking at now is a rolling chassis
[attach=1]
The boiler is the final one 28 x 40 mm with 15mls of water it took 2mins to steam up then there was a spurt of water lasted about 1sec then it ran non-stop for 5mins just what i wanted
[attach=2]
With the compressor attached it can be walked like a dog up to a point the black wheels ( 1 5/8" ) came as spares along with axles when i bought a Stirling engine they were the ones i first tried but the gearing was a little to slow
[attach=3]
You can see i bought some plastic gears and i found a gear with 56teeth along with the yellow wheels which are 2"dia. and dare i say the speed for me is just perfect of course depending what engine you use you may have to change the gearing when it was running across my table top i laid a pair of pliers on top and it just kept running. So now i`m really back to the experimental stage waiting for a proper UV joint to arrive hopefully Thursday what i intend to do is to add weight until it stops moving don`t really know if that`s what i should do.........open to comment
Lastly what i need to do before i get serious is to try and work out a burner arrangement so Jim or anyone if you are reading this i`m open to suggestion if a car is what you like to make the transmission works a treat
-
Very nice progress.
I am really enjoying this build thread.
Thank you!
-
Hopefully now i can show you what i meant by a steam platform
[attach=1]
instead of steam i propose to fit my small compressor it`s tube is about a meter long and the elect cable the same which really should give me 6feet to play with when cable connected to wall socket that way i should be able to change gear to suit the wheel dia used so really a wee useful tool
[attach=2]
The mockup just sat on top never measured the platform or anything and dare i say nearly exact i think it must be an omen. Remember the platform is only a tool.
Still waiting for bits and pieces to arrive so who knows
-
Frazer very nice i have bookmarked it and will study it later many thanks
Update so far what i said about a steam platform you will see at the end
[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]
[attach=4]
Hopefully you can see what i have been up to the UV joint will be replaced it had been bored out to 3mm where as the shaft this time is 2.3mm and is too wobbly new one on order. Shaft this time is quite short wanted to see how short i could go lengthwise as a result the shaft is light that`s why you will see the spring otherwise it won`t engage properly the gear is just one i picked out the scrap box and may not be the final one. Once the correct gear is found the spring can be adjusted for correct tension the two vertical bolts are there to keep the worm in line with the gear.
-
Just thought you may like to see this site. The wee Pie wagon is my favourite and very tempting
http://www.horselesscarriagereplicas.com/plans.html
cheers
frazer
-
Frazer many thanks for your input small torch arrived this morning
Stoker what you say is 100% correct this morning i was going to build the Cadillac carriage drew up the frame to cover in 1mm plywood the windows in the doors open up and down just like the old loco doors in the UK railway and not in and out then i stopped to think how would you protect it from the burner flame same with the wheels the smaller the scale the nearer the flame
[attach=1]
Scale is a problem ( hate to keep mentioning the French boys they start with the wheel ) i don`t think there are enough days left on the planet for me to make such things that`s why the size came out as it did wheels i had already.
[attach=2]
Bought two of these many years ago for the great grand children for the princely sum of £3 and they have just lay unopened on top of a cupboard forgot all about them kids today seem to prefer there smart phones or computer. I think the road i have to go down is to make a steam working platform to iron out the transmission worm drive preferred how many people can tell you the ratio for a 1" or 2" or 3" wheel NONE then there is JIm`s vertical/horizontal drive on a smaller scale would help to find what pulley sizes would be required so you see still many things to think of. Would be nice to see some of your own builds even failure or otherwise that way we can all learn
Thank you for your input
-
I also love the mock-up, it certainly shows a lot of potential.
Scale is the problem factor I find in many of my builds. When trying to keep something fairly small, you run into all kinds of problems of fit, function and finish. Generally the larger scale you build to, the easier that build will be to accomplish, but then material costs / weight / handling / storage issues start becoming major factors as well.
Somewhere there is the perfect compromise on what scale to use for any given build, but for us mere humans, perfection in anything is most always unachievable!
-
Plenty of good info https://www.cupalloys.co.uk/for-model-engineers
Good luck
-
Frazer yes twin tube boiler could be used ( some of the French boys have gone down that route ) if i had just stuck to the title i.e. mini steam car i would have been ok the fact i wanted to make it scale is really the problem and the fact i mentioned Cadillac made things worse at that period no mater which model you choose they seem to be the car with the smallest bonnet/hood. For those of you find it hard to make a bonnet have a look at this
[attach=1]
Fail Legano A6 paint scorching would be the problem but it lets you see there are hundreds out there let`s wait and see i think i will come up with some thing. Would be grateful for some info on silver soldering the test boiler i made used up the last of my s.s.rods which were 1.5mm i have since bought 0.5 and 0.7 s.s. wire ( don`t know why maybe price ) and bought the smallish type torch Danny suggested (still to arrive ) Torch i have too large for sheet metal so any info on that will be helpful. Now i will try and put pen to paper towards the end of the week something will happen
-
Would a twin drum water tubed boiler fit in that space
-
Not sure what to suggest, but really enjoyed the mock-up
-
Some extra food for thought[attach=1][attach=2][attach=3]
Size wise it`s not exactly 100% but not far off
[attach=4]
Here you can see another option using larger wheels ( 3 1/2" ) could also make a locomobile . I think i will start again and make a steam platform even if it`s only an oblong sheet with a wheel at each corner that way the engine could be fitted as you see on the test bed or it could be turned round and fitted side ways belts and pulleys used for transmission although i would prefer to use worm drive so you see i still have many things to think about
P.S. larger wheel 2 1/2" NOT 3 1/2"
-
Will post pics first [attach=1][attach=2][attach=3]
You can now see space is going to be a little tight boiler will be made from copper end caps i was going to spin on reflection i think i will just visit the plumb centre and buy a couple if nothing else i at least know the size to make it
-
Made the mock up out of card instead of wood but there are some things i really need to think about[attach=1][attach=2][attach=3][attach=4]
-
Nice Ron, this is getting interesting 8)
-
Keep the photos coming Ron.
-
Ron:
This is a great project.
I will be following with great interest.
Regards,
Charlie
-
Tried some templates today and think i will make a wooden mock up first [attach=1]
You will see that model H has a longer bonnet/hood which will really suit my boiler want to increase it to 1 1/8" dia where as Model M seems to have a higher cab [attach=2][attach=3] Size wise frame is 185 x 64mm --1/ 4 x 1/4 x 1/16" Wheels are 2" Wheel base 5 3/4" don`t know it that will stand as a mini car
Like the French say you have to learn to walk before you can run
-
Hopefully now i have the boiler sorted out the real problem was the the burner wick first time the dia was too small tried another burner with a wick dia of 6mm and it seemed to work except it stopped once after 5mins
Thought i would try out an open framework this time[attach=1]
Holding it square was a little of a problem but after the first corner not so bad rest of the pics just to give me an idea[attach=2][attach=3][attach=4]
P.S. silver soldered still to clean up
-
Trying for third time[attach=1][attach=2][attach=3] just to say problem solved ( bigger burner wick worked) engine ran non-stop for 5mins exact gave a flick it ran for further 3 1/2mins with 15mls of water thinking if i tack a pipe inside tube before soldering end plate might be an improvement
-
Nick just spent 20mins writing a reply and nothing happened
-
Ron, I'm in to follow this along. Thanks for posting up the build process.
-
I'm late to the thread but catching up fast - really interesting and will be fun to follow!
-
The reason I wanted outlet coming from the side is because the smaller I make the car the less clearance there will be between the boiler and the bonnet/hood if I make the car non-scale then it won't really matter maybe the outlet is too low remember this is only a test boiler will have a rethink tomorrow
-
If you're getting too wet of steam, another solution would be running a copper steam line out of the boiler and under, through the flame to the engine, or maybe trying a small steam dome on top of the boiler if you want to stick with silicone line.
-
Nick it does seem so it looks as if you can follow water down the clear tube to the engine and it just bubbles out of the rev. connection thats why i thought it might run better upside down the fact it keeps stopping I think it's because of the small dia. wick in the burner when you said yours took a lot of flame made me think.
-
I wonder if a big problem with running to slow is if your steam is too wet?
-
Material did arrive for the boiler i picked brass thinking it would be lighter than copper but the tube that arrived was thick walled and i thought due to its small dia i would machine the end caps as usual no material but i did have plenty 3mm brass plate so i cut a square and stuck it on to a small face plate with double sided tape also used a live tail stock steady but it moved so i tried again using 5min epoxy gave it 2 hours moved again then put it in a small 4 jaw chuck got so far then the tool just dug in.[attach=1]
So i just silver soldered the end caps now it was time to try it out. A 1" x 2" boiler gives a capacity of 22mil (round figure ) to start i put in 15mls
Sitting in the green house with the bedroom clock strapped to my wrist i lite the burner. The first run it ran for 1 1/2 mins then stopped it ran for a further 6mins which gave me a total of 7 1/2 mins so a little encouraged checked the boiler and remove 4mls of water the second run i put in 10mls of water again it stopped after 1 1/2mins then stopped again after 2 1/2 mins started again then 2 1/2 stopped boiler dry. I should have said i ran it yesterday for the first time under air just to check which connection was fwd and rev. and it ran like a Rocket and i thought no good i will never be able to reduce the revs will be really to fast. Today under steam it was the opposite too slow [attach=2] note the safety vale just a modern version of what Tubal Cain used ( he used cork on some of his boilers ) you will see in the next pics where i could see some leeks[attach=3][attach=4] hopefully the pics are ok. Would really like to hear from someone who has the same engine how to make good connections and if maybe this engine runs better upside down. Should have said when starting under steam the flywheel rotates ever so slowly on its own really giving me the impression it would self start (before giving the flywheel a flick ) if press was great enough i`m sure this will self start. Really wanted to move on chassis maybe but need to find solutions to boiler first maybe should submit to Sandy boiler design for boiler of the year award ????
-
Looks like an interesting build Ron.
I will be following and looking forward to the next update.
-
I think it was the Chinese who said the hardest part of a long march was the first step
So the first step
Make yourself a test bed and what you see is simple to make the copper tube is for another project and the meths burner is only for test purposes boiler material hopefully will arrive later this week. The object here is to see how long it will take the boiler to run dry and the amount of meths to do so, no point making a boiler sticking it in a car only to find out it only runs for 2mins so making i little rig like this will hopefully produce the answers. Also i will be able to adjust the height of the meths burner so that i can determine the optimum space between the top of the wick and the boiler bottom remember the boiler size 1" x 1 3/4" long mabye 2" max
[attachimg=2][attach=3][attachimg=4]
-
Looking forward to this Ron
-
This will be fun to follow, please take lots of pics 8)
-
I'll be watching this Ron, I love build threads.
-
This year i`m going to attempt to build a mini steam car duration min 5mins. Two i have in mind are the 1905/6 REO or the 1906 cadillac still to find blue prints for it ,looks a bit of an oddity but i think it was the first car to have an enclosed cab. Firstly if i treat the build as Boiler, Burner,Engine, Transmission and so on i think will be easier to explain my thinking the boiler i hope i can get away with 1"dia x 1 3/4"long the engine a microcosm, m28. So miles to go
][attachimg=2][attachimg=3]