Office of Steam Forum for Model & Toy Steam Gas & Hot Air Engines

Builds, Repairs, Show Your Machines! => Technical Tips, Builds, and Help => Topic started by: St Paul Steam on May 14, 2021, 10:14:26 pm

Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Jim on May 16, 2021, 06:20:08 pm
That's very very clever Bruce.
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: parallelmotion on May 16, 2021, 09:53:21 am
Have you ever considered a career in foot modeling Walter? You may get some offers after that post. I must say I was too distracted to notice the valve, but now that I see it, that's a great tool. Most Marklin boiler threads match one of the US fractional fine threads although I can't recall which one at the moment. I've never tried pulling out a dent but have always done it the hard way by opening up the boiler, but that's really difficult with many Marklins which have silver soldered flues.
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Damnfmaschine on May 16, 2021, 08:31:28 am
Nice work Bruce. Nice feet Walter.
Maybe I should have put some gloves (socks) on Brent; did you notice that the Schroder tyre valve thread fits nicely in a Marklin bushing? I’ve even used as steam fitting.
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Paula on May 15, 2021, 11:30:28 pm

This Wilesco D101 (like most Wilesco's) has a slip eccentric and was mearly running backwards I suppose , I wasn't paying attention to that detail...lol (good catch) with a flip of the flywheel it can easily be made to change direction.

As Emily Litella would say, "Never mind..."


Quote
Re:Jensen #35 I believe I have a spare boiler for that particular engine , its yours for the taking if you want it. (Free)

I think the Model 35 (Why did I say "D35"?) project may have just moved up the list! (Look for a PM)

Thanks,
Paula
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: St Paul Steam on May 15, 2021, 09:45:08 pm
Similar here; I’m known to apply pressure using bare feet (or bear feet if a tame bear can be found)
(Attachment Link)
Walter , I'm a firm believer in "whatever works" I have some very unorthodox methods to doing things that a  trained machinists would never do , but I do...if I find that it works , I just don't know enough "not" to know that it shouldn't work 😄👍
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: St Paul Steam on May 15, 2021, 09:40:49 pm
Hi Bruce,

Thanks for the helpful videos! This seems to be a fairly common problem, especially with the smaller, low pressure boilers.

In fact, I have a Jensen D35 that apparently took a hard hit to the flywheel, from the direction of the stack. This bent the crankshaft bracket severely in the opposite direction, and made a nasty crease in the boiler. Less noticeable was bending the shaft (wobbly flywheel) and crankpin. Someone "fixed" it by just bending the bracket back so that the damage is less visible. Something I'll have to reckon with when I get around to that engine. (It has other issues, as well.)

Watching your third video, with the engine running, I note that it seems to be running in the opposite direction that most engines run (connecting rod goes under the crank when piston extends.) Most non-reversing engines seem to be valved to go the opposite direction. I don't know what the convention is, or even if there is one. Curiously, the engine in the video, as it's set up, runs the grinder and saw in the wrong direction, assuming the operator would be standing opposite the drive belts. As I say, curious.  ???

Nice work!
Paula
This Wilesco D101 (like most Wilesco's) has a slip eccentric and was mearly running backwards I suppose , I wasn't paying attention to that detail...lol (good catch) with a flip of the flywheel it can easily be made to change direction.
Re:Jensen #35 I believe I have a spare boiler for that particular engine , its yours for the taking if you want it. (Free)
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: parallelmotion on May 15, 2021, 08:56:50 pm
Nice work Bruce. Nice feet Walter.
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Paula on May 15, 2021, 08:55:25 pm
Hi Bruce,

Thanks for the helpful videos! This seems to be a fairly common problem, especially with the smaller, low pressure boilers.

In fact, I have a Jensen D35 that apparently took a hard hit to the flywheel, from the direction of the stack. This bent the crankshaft bracket severely in the opposite direction, and made a nasty crease in the boiler. Less noticeable was bending the shaft (wobbly flywheel) and crankpin. Someone "fixed" it by just bending the bracket back so that the damage is less visible. Something I'll have to reckon with when I get around to that engine. (It has other issues, as well.)

Watching your third video, with the engine running, I note that it seems to be running in the opposite direction that most engines run (connecting rod goes under the crank when piston extends.) Most non-reversing engines seem to be valved to go the opposite direction. I don't know what the convention is, or even if there is one. Curiously, the engine in the video, as it's set up, runs the grinder and saw in the wrong direction, assuming the operator would be standing opposite the drive belts. As I say, curious.  ???

Nice work!
Paula
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Damnfmaschine on May 15, 2021, 08:28:45 am
[attach=1]
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Damnfmaschine on May 15, 2021, 08:23:18 am
[attach=1]
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Damnfmaschine on May 15, 2021, 08:20:47 am
Similar here; I’m known to apply pressure using bare feet (or bear feet if a tame bear can be found)
[attachimg=1]
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: St Paul Steam on May 15, 2021, 06:11:14 am
Thanks for the comments folks , I tried to remember most of the tricks I learned from you folks over the years , I did chuck the brass rod into my vise  (while screwed into the boiler bush) & used a light prying method with a piece of pine wood , & while under stress I tapped the dented high spots with a small brass hammer. I assumed I would need to un-solder the end cap & have a go at it that way, & I think that way may have worked slightly better...but I'm happy with it as is. interestingly the bush stayed soldered until the very end , I re:liquefied the solder as I'm sure it got cracked somewhere in the manipulating process. what I'm baffled by... in looking at the severity of the dent, how did the whistle or steam line not get crushed ?
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: classixs on May 15, 2021, 04:03:00 am
Looks great now, well done Bruce!

Exact same method i use here, if the dent is soft enough to be yanked back in place from the outside.
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Dampfopa on May 15, 2021, 03:51:22 am
Good job Bruce. Interesting to see how you got the dent out of the boiler. Much less effort than soldering out a boiler bottom and pushing the dent out from the inside. I have a similar method. I do this by taking a piece of plastic tubing that is the same diameter as the boiler, cutting it to the appropriate length and then dividing it lengthwise. Then I drill a hole the diameter of the receiving hole in the boiler at the appropriate point. The jig is slipped over the spot with the dent and the screw is tightened until the dent is pulled out. Sometimes, depends on the dent, then need to rework a little on your method.

[attach=2]
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: Stoker on May 15, 2021, 12:33:13 am
Well done on working that dent out of the top of that boiler Bruce! Looking at it as received, I wouldn't have thought it could possibly come out that well!!!
Title: Re: boiler dent pull
Post by: ShadetreeMotorcycle on May 14, 2021, 11:19:13 pm
Great Informative video's Bruce, thanks for sharing!
Title: boiler dent pull
Post by: St Paul Steam on May 14, 2021, 10:14:26 pm
Hi folks , I received this little Wilesco D101 in the mail today, it was purchased with the knowledge that it had quite a pushed in dent where the whistle resides, I was very pleased with the overall plant & that it was a bit more rare with the factory belly heater. I filmed my little dent removal process (well most of it) have a look.
 as received...

https://youtu.be/6hzEU8ZijAA

giving a little tug

https://youtu.be/bEXJaESOgZM

all good & running

https://youtu.be/RR3eqqvZSEo