Office of Steam Forum for Model & Toy Steam Gas & Hot Air Engines
The Regular Stuff: Chat, Buy, Sell, Off Topic, etc. => General Discussion - Model & Toy Steam Engines – Stirling Cycle – Flame Lickers – Small Antique Originals => Topic started by: Jim on March 31, 2019, 10:58:16 pm
-
Ok ok I’m good with air. Let’s see some engines running!
-
Thanks all, appreciated the replies.
Now that I have my you beaut air setup in my workshop (why I didn't set it up better years ago beats me) I have been running and fine tuning lots of engine.
Its a LOT easier using air than burning ones fingers continuously using steam :) :) :)
So yes, I might be posting up some engines running on air now and again :)
-
I test engines on air, and usually test them later on steam as well when I know all the connections etc. are intact.
As for watching a video of an engine run it really doesn't matter to me, the mechanics work the same, flywheels wobble just as much. :)
-
I agree Pete!
-
I think I will get this put on a T-Shirt!
Should be the forum motto Charlie.
-
to "air" is human....but to "steam" is divine....lol
I think I will get this put on a T-Shirt!
-
Do I like watching engines “run” on air?
No, I prefer to watch them “walk” on water ;)
Ok... I’ll get me coat with Pete ;) :D :D
I'll get it for you mate
-
Air is convenient, and the only option at many shows these days.
Steam is more fun, though....
-
Air is fine ... Steam is better!!!
Agree completely (https://emoji.tapatalk-cdn.com/emoji482.png)
-
I have to say i much prefer steam to air. However air is useful when running in or testing, however the true test will always be under live steam.
-
Steam engines are a most elegant form of motive power and to me this rings true on steam and air. I also like running them slowly.
-
to "air" is human....but to "steam" is divine....lol
Well said - reminds me of Odgen Nash!
-
I often run them on air, as long as you put a drop of lubricating oil (not steam oil) down the intake it's ok..... :)
Allan.
-
I prefer to run on steam it has that sound and smell you don't get with air but saying that air does a good job if you don't want the mess of clearing up.
-
Do I like watching engines “run” on air?
No, I prefer to watch them “walk” on water ;)
Ok... I’ll get me coat with Pete ;) :D :D
-
I run them both on air and steam.
Doesn’t bother me either way.
To each his own......
-
Air is for testing
Steam is the real deal .
And in my opinion any fool can make a engine that runs on air .
It is not a steam engine untill it has run on steam .
And while we are at it i do not like those videos of slow motion done digitally.
If you want to show a engine running slow do it properly in real time on steam.
-
to "air" is human....but to "steam" is divine....lol
I like that saying Bruce :)
-
Air is fine ... Steam is better!!!
to "air" is human....but to "steam" is divine....lol
-
I guess I'm of the same opinion as most of the folks I read here. Steam is really what these engine were built to run on and there is something about having the whole system running that brings a smile to my face. That being said, air is easier, quicker to set up and take down, and safer when little ones are around.
A good point.
-
I guess I'm of the same opinion as most of the folks I read here. Steam is really what these engine were built to run on and there is something about having the whole system running that brings a smile to my face. That being said, air is easier, quicker to set up and take down, and safer when little ones are around.
-
Running on air is better than not running at all. Steam is so much more dynamic. Better sound, much more power, a little element of risk. Steam makes better pictures and video. So I guess I’m all steam but big engines on air is always good enough.
-
I run on air when fixing/testing or for a quick
show-off, but really, it is not as satisfying as
getting a persnickety burner and engine to
run like they should. I will say this, I steamup
my electrics more often than my burners.
Steamed 3 empires last night - I was a bit down
so I steamed 'em up until the blues went away.
Wayne
-
I prefer steam, but air is preferable over not running at all!
-
Air is fine ... Steam is better!!!
-
If I would get off my dead rear end and work on some projects I would run more on steam but for now air is an easier option - they're made to run on steam but air works okay for me.
-
Jim, I use air when I want to run cast iron cylinder engines like several Stuarts. A few of my Stuarts do not have drain valves on the cylinders, so I feel better running air vs. leave moisture for rust to set in. Also, it's a good option as a test bed. BUT, by and large most of my engines do get steamed if they have brass/bronze cylinders.
Rog
-
Jim: I may seem a little odd but I run my true
antique engines on air only and not for extended
periods. I do have several Mamod and Wiilesco
engines that I can Steam. Old Engines with brass
boilers can present dangerous problems. Ron - steamtoys
[
-
Out of convenience I run them on air often , doesn't bother me either way.
-
Just out of curiosity do you like seeing engines run on air?